Orange Theory Review

April 1, 2014 · 10 comments

I first heard about Orange Theory in Southern California. After doing a little research, I discovered they were rapidly expanding across the country with over 250 locations! This group interval training class incorporates both treadmills and indoor rowing machines with strength training exercises all while wearing heart rate monitors that display your heart rate and HR zone on a large screen for the duration of class. While visiting Miami last weekend, I was able to finally try it myself!

IMG 6752

Your first class is free so I called up and made a reservation Saturday morning. The class was full but they told me to come in and would try to get me in. Once I arrived, the front deskers handed me a Polar chest strap to put around my torso. The instructor brought myself and the other first timers into the studio to show us how to use the treadmill and row machine.

IMG 6755

If you can’t tell by the pictures and name, Orange Theory is lit with orange light bulbs.

“The physiological theory behind the Orangetheory workout is known as “Excess Post-Exercise Oxygen Consumption,” or EPOC. By providing you with a heart rate monitor and POD, we can monitor your 5 zone interval training sessions that we call the Orange 60. During the 60 minute workout, you will perform multiple intervals designed to produce 12-20 minutes of training at 84% or higher of your maximum heart rate, which translates to Zones 4/5. This program design produces EPOC, which is the workout “after-burn” effect, meaning that our interval training design produces a 200-400 calorie increase to your metabolism 24-36 hours after your workout.

However, judging by the results of my class, I think it should be called, Green Theory since that was the zone most of us were in the majority of the time…

IMG 6753

The Class:

At the start, I was given a Polar sensor to attach to my chest strap. I started on the treadmill at a warm up pace. Half of the class was on the rower and half on the treads. We all went at an easy pace for about 5 minutes mixing between a slow jog and fast run, alternating each minute. I felt like the treadmill was slower than the speed indicated but I liked the treadmill interface which made it easy to switch from a fast to slow speed with the touch of one button. I tried hard to get into the orange zone, but it just didn’t happen.

IMG 6754

After the warm up, the rowers went over to the free weight and bench area. My group moved to the rowers. We were told to row 400 meters as fast as we could, then hop up to our treadmill and run as far as we could with the time remaining in the five minute interval. 1…2…3… GO!

We did this interval four times, adding incline to the last couple of treadmill runs. The instructor gave out many different recommendations for speeds during the beginning of class for beginners which was good to see.

IMG 6756

Next, we swapped with the free weight area people. On the floor, we saw three moves up on a separate screen from our heart rates. They were simple and beginner friendly. We were told to do 15 reps of each move, and once we finished start from the top. We were aiming to get through between 2 and 4 sets. The first round exercises used a TRX and were a little beginner for my me. We had about 5 minutes per round. We had 4 different rounds featuring 3 different exercises. The exercises were always displayed on the screen except the last set which was helpful however I’m curious if the screen usually displays your heart rate which we couldn’t see during the workout. The moves hit most body parts and the last focused on core. We did exercises like bicep curls, reverse lunges, plank walk outs, and russian twists. At the end, our final calorie burn was displayed and a graph showing what zones we were in during our workout (image above).

What I liked:

  • The class has a nice learning curve. Beginners shouldn’t be intimidated. My instructor provided modifications where needed.
  • I really liked the music!
  • The instructor knew what he was talking about, looked VERY in shape and not bad to look at either. His name was Juan but is on the schedule as Juanster.
  • After class, my heart rate summary was emailed right to me for future tracking. It was fun to watch it during the rowing and running portion of class.
  • Moves were safe and effective, easy to learn. Directions were clear.
Areas I think they could improve on:
  • The instructor wasn’t very vocal about intervals, when to switch and when to stop. Kind of quiet and I didn’t feel inspired to push myself. I heard my instructor say start and then the encouragement stopped there. We were left to push ourselves while staring at our heart rate overhead. I would have liked more intervals on the treadmill with countdowns and all.
  • Kind of on the beginner side of things and neglected the more advanced clients, but this may be due to the demographic of Coral Gables, not necessarily the instructor. However, I do think it’s important to give advanced modifications as much as for beginners.
  • Pace of class felt slow. We moved slowly from one circuit to the next and had a lot of rest time in between.

The rower was hard for me but once I got on that treadmill, I couldn’t get fast enough to get my heart rate actually pumping hard despite running at 9 for 2.5 minutes. Their class recommends your sprint as being 2 points faster than a jog. I can sprint at a 12.5 but my jog max is a 7. I know Barry’s has conditioned me but I swear the tread was slower than what it read out. I ran at a 10 for a minute which I never do at home and finally saw my heart rate rise! I missed countdowns and motivation to run faster but it was also peacefull being able to go at my own pace.

IMG 6758

I was glad I ran into the founder of Rate Your Burn (who also gave me my first review – holy nerves knowing she was in class) last week to hear her thoughts on Orange Theory. While she has yet to take a class, she mentioned that she heard it was supposed to be more like a CrossFit hybrid which I hadn’t thought about! During the class, I kept comparing it to Barry’s Bootcamp but now I feel like I shouldn’t have. I have yet to experience a REAL CrossFit class because the ones I always take are 15 minutes of actual work and 45 minutes of stretching… but I can see how OTheory is like a mix between CrossFit and Bootcamp with Polar HR tracking.
I liked the class. I didn’t love it because I didn’t feel personally pushed enough on the treadmill or floor but with another instructor, location or class time, that might change. They are opening up a location in Brighton, MA soon and I will definitely give it another try.
Have you been to Orange Theory yet? What did you think of the class, was it similar to mine?

{ 10 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Laura April 1, 2014 at 12:25 pm

I have been doing orange theory for about 4 months, and am actually bummed that you didn’t love it. What I will say is that every class is totally different, and the intensity completely depends on the instructor. The format of your class is the most common format, but there is another where you do treads, rowing, and weights in a row and repeat 4 times. You might enjoy that pace a little bit more, but I always think the class flies by!

Reply

2 Sarah April 1, 2014 at 12:48 pm

Have you tried a Barry’s Bootcamp class? I think the reason I wasn’t crazy about it was because I was comparing it the whole time in my head – which I should not have done. I’m going to take another class and I think it totally depends on your instructor.

Reply

3 Ashley @ A Lady Goes West April 1, 2014 at 1:11 pm

Hi Sarah,

Thanks for this recap. There is an Orange Theory in San Francisco, where I live, and I’ve been wanting to try it. I teach Les Mills group fitness classes, so I have pretty high standards when it comes to coaching and instruction, as well as music. I hope to try Orange Theory out for myself, since it is a different concept. But yes, the instructor’s style is a huge deal to making or breaking an experience.

Best,
Ashley
aladygoeswest.com

Reply

4 Alison @ The Fit Chronicles April 1, 2014 at 2:15 pm

Thanks for this review!! I’ve been planning to try the Coral Gables Orange Theory because I live nearby. I’m not as skilled of a runner as you, so I hopefully will pop into the orange zone!

Reply

5 Joan April 1, 2014 at 4:37 pm

Hi Sarah:

Orange Theory has made its way into Canada where I live. St Albert, AB was the very FIRST one in Canada!!! Pretty cool. I joined opening night October 2012…..I am still a member, however I found that you can get bored of it very easily. I do mix it up with a home gym and weight lifting. You get used to each instructor and I found myself only going if my fav instructor was teaching. It is different every day and with every instructor, but I really LOVE the music and that I can work at my own pace. Push when I want to and compete against the other members,,,,,,I always try to beat the person next to me weither it be on the threadmill or rowing machine….I did find that I could make it into the orange on the ALL OUT pace…but the BASE PACE and the PUSH PACE, I was in the green zone. I think it is a great workout for beginner to advanced athletes as you can customize it to your needs. You can power walk with incline or run all out….the choice is yours. Thanks fore reviewing Sarah!!

Joan

Reply

6 Ryah April 1, 2014 at 7:20 pm

It sounds like the OTF you went too was kind of slow pace wise. I’ve been going to an OTF in Newport Beach, CA for about six months now and I love it. (Sadly I have to cancel my membership because I’m moving, but I hear they’re opening an OTF in Long Beach, CA where I’m moving too soon.) That said the intensity totally depends on the instructor, but also you (how fast you’re willing to set your base/push/all out paces for that day, choosing heavier weights, etc.) How long were you in the orange zone for if you don’t mind me asking? The first time I went the format confused me, but after I understood it more I was always able to hit the orange zone for at least the recommended 12 minutes, usually more.

Reply

7 Sarah April 1, 2014 at 7:23 pm

Yeah – I totally get that which is why I tried to emphasize the fact that another visit was in the cards. I was in the orange zone for just 5 minutes :( haha

Reply

8 Sarah April 2, 2014 at 10:38 pm

Have you ever tried the Zone5 class at Beacon Hill Athletic Club? Sounds similar but I love it! It’s also a heart rate monitor class where you try to get in Zone5 (just like getting to orange) and they display heart rate and calories burned on the screen. It’s structured with 15 exercises: 4 cardio and 11 strength exercises. You do each exercise for 2 minutes then rest for one minute. The best part is the instructor shows you all the exercises at the beginning but then during the workout no two people are doing the same thing. It’s nice because you can really focus on yourself and not what other people are doing. I highly recommend it! It kicked my butt :) I’ve never tried Barry’s but I really want to. These strength training / cardio classes are a lot of fun.

Reply

9 Steph Clark April 4, 2014 at 10:59 am

Hi Sarah,

I love the idea of not having to do HIIT training alone, it can get a little boring! This class sounds perfect for me as I love a mixture of interval cardio and strength training, I would love to try it!

Rowing and running are the two forms of cardio which I find most challenging and also that I feel get my heart rate up the most! Will definitely try a similar workout!

Please check out my blog, I’m new to fitness blogging and would love to get your opinion!

Reply

10 Jenn May 16, 2014 at 1:13 pm

I’ve been curious about Orange Theory also, because I too am ADDICTED to Barry’s! But I read about Orange theory being the new rage from Well & Good. I’m just wondering its as much “fun” as Barry’s … it does sound more like crossfit, which I’ve also started enjoying, but mostly because I like seeing my progression in strength, not because its as exhausting/exhilarating as Barry’s. I like that feeling at Barry’s that everyone is suffering together. With crossfit, as time passes, people are doing different things because they do their reps faster than others or run further faster during their WOD, which I don’t like as much as the Barry’s format. Besides, the 30 minutes of sprint intervals + 30 min weights at Barry’s just kills me, just a harder workout (more slimming!) than 20-40 min WODs.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: